People always ask the question, ” Why do footballers get yellow cards for shirt-off celebrations?
It seems unreasonable that a player has just scored an amazing goal, and he wants to celebrate it with his fans by taking off his shirt but gets punished for that.
That makes no sense, but there are very serious reasons for the existence of that law that prohibits this kind of celebration in modern football.
Liverpool forward Hugo Ekitike was a victim of that. He was already on a yellow card and received another yellow card for removing his shirt after scoring the winner against Southampton in a 2-1 Carabao Cup, which resulted in his red card.
Now Eketike is suspended for Liverpool’s next Premier League match. This latest fact shows why players need to acknowledge how they celebrate goals even when scored at crucial times.
The International Football Association Board (IFAB), the ruling body that determines the laws of the game, law 12.4 states that it is mandatory for a player to be cautioned when removing their shirt or for covering their head with the shirt. This rule has applied worldwide since 2004 to every football match taking place.
IFAB said that players could celebrate when a goal is scored but should not be excessive.
According to them, choreographed celebrations should not be encouraged nor result in wasting too much time.
The lawmakers would like to maintain control in managing the celebrations without removing the players’ expressions of joy.
All kinds of harm can occur with players when taking off their shirts. From irritating the opposing team and fans to using space for political messages, wasting time, and covering the sponsors of clubs. Every one of those justifies why people take this law so seriously.
The reason players have violated so many rules is that they do not understand this rule; even the expert stars forget it every now and then due to the inevitable consequence of celebration after scoring an important goal.
The Story Behind the Rule
The very introduction of this offense dates back to 2004, rightly because in some cultures exposing the torso was an offensive thing.
FIFA and other football parties wanted to respect those diverse expositions across cultures that exist worldwide.
The rule also prevents players from staging political messages or unsuitable content on their undershirts.
Some players started using goal celebrations to communicate controversial statements. In dire need, they want to prevent that from occurring in matches.
Manchester United‘s Diego Forlan had one of the most infamous moments when he took his shirt off after scoring against Southampton during the 2002-03 season.
Caught on an inner vest, his shirt would not go back on, and the game resumed with the Uruguayan having to play sans top.
This embarrassing incident hastened the emergence of the new rule.
An equally major cause for which this law was introduced was time-wasting.
The time represented for putting on the shirts after a celebration took too long, which disrupted the game and irked fans and officials alike. The automatic yellow card rule uprooted the issue immediately.
This law was also influenced by another issue related to sponsor protection. Sponsorship deals in millions of pounds come into football clubs through their shirts.
The sponsors lose much valuable TV exposure when players tear them off in celebration. This financial part contributed to the ban on shirt-removal celebrations.
The rule goes from the grassroots through to the World Cup final. No matter the situation or importance of the goal, referees must show that yellow card. In the football world, there are no exceptions to this law at all.
Since the induction of the law, this has led to many high-profile episodes wherein a player stripped and was cautioned.
During a very important match, many celebrities have had to learn this lesson in the hardest possible way.
Famous Players Who Got Caught and Were Shown a Yellow Card
Amad Diallo’s last-minute goal against Liverpool in 2024 saw him being sent off after he enthusiastically ran into the crowd to celebrate with his shirt off.
The Cameroon international overstepped the mark and was duly shown a yellow card by the referee for what they saw as an excessive celebration.
Not the wisest decision for a player representing one of the two top clubs in English football and also in a big match like that.
Demarai Gray got a yellow card for taking off his jersey in tribute to the owner of Leicester City, who had died in a helicopter crash.
The admiration of the crowd, as against his tribute to the late owner, didn’t spoil his name in the referee’s eyes for the final moments of the game.
Among all the improper and funny incidents in Mario Balotelli’s career, one of the most memorable remains the time he celebrated shirtless against Germany at Euro 2012.
All told, Balotelli’s days were marked by wild actions, where still his celebrations fell within the parameters of the laws governing them.
Cameroonian forward Vincent Aboubakar was sent off at the 2022 World Cup after scoring a stoppage-time goal to send his team to the finals.
His dramatic goal would have been talked about for years, yet Aboubakar was sent off for a petty incident in the fag end of the match.
Carlos Tevez got booked when he dedicated his score to his dying grandfather, a gesture that was not really condemnation-worthy but nevertheless brought with it a card.
It was his grandfather, after all, and none could scold him for holding him sacrosanct in his celebrations.
Robbie Keane was also punished by a referee, as he received a yellow card for taking off his shirt after scoring for Ireland in a World Cup qualifier.
The experienced forward knew his conduct was out of order and could be punished, but the moment had gotten to him, so he went ahead and did it anyway, and surely he got punished.
It really shows that even the most experienced players can commit this error at any given moment! It is wisdom from the lords of football that the excess of joy upon scoring a goal tends to shut out everything else.
What Most Fans Think About This Rule
Opinions about whether this law is just or too harsh are somewhat mixed among football supporters.
The punishment is too harsh, in some fans’ eyes, for what they consider an innocent celebration, while others feel the rules should be followed no matter what.
Many fans are unhappy with this law, stating that removing a shirt is not dangerous play and that there are other more important fouls deserving of such punishment.
Such fans demand for yellow cards to be divided into more categories according to the severity of the acts.
Technical fouls like shirt removal should bear a lesser punishment, while dangerous tackles bear greater ones.
Some supporters understand the reasoning behind the rule but believe it should only apply if a player is already on a yellow card.
This would decrease the number of players being sent off for goal celebrations. It would still put a damper on the conduct without ruining important matches.
Other fans feel that the ban is completely fair and that the players should just know better. They say professional footballers earn so much money for such a simple task; they should face the penalties for bringing disgrace upon themselves by breaking these basic rules.
How fans interpret this rule also varies culturally. More conservative societies tend to support a ban on removing shirts, while others consider such perceptions to be an intrusion into natural celebrations.
The global debate rages on across fan circles. Yet, the law remains, and its enforcement remains stringent, while players are adjusting their acts of celebration to remain within the law of the game.
The introduction of social media takes this discussion a bit higher. Instant opinion-sharing regarding controversial incidents puts pressure on referees and lawmakers to rethink their guidelines.
The football authorities seem unlikely to change the rule, despite the backlash from fans. They say it works as intended, keeping all unwanted behavior in check. Therefore, players and fans will have to continue living with the aforementioned regulations.
Mentioned in the News Story
📢 Stay Updated with Us!
Join our channels for the latest sports news, live updates, and more:
✅ WhatsApp 📢 Telegram